Eight years after Cape Town, the man caught with the sandpaper has finally told his full story, and it lands like a bouncer aimed squarely at Australia's current captain.
Former Australia opener Cameron Bancroft has alleged that the entire Australian team knew he was using sandpaper on the ball during the 2018 Test tour of South Africa, not just himself, then-captain Steve Smith and vice-captain David Warner. In a statement of more than 4,000 words, first published by the West Australian on Wednesday, November 18, and later distributed to all media, Bancroft admitted he had "never been completely honest about what happened," according to BBC Sport. His account directly contradicts Test captain Pat Cummins, who has repeatedly denied that he or the bowlers knew sandpaper was being used. Cummins, through his manager, says his position has not changed.
It is important to be clear about what this is: a detailed personal account from one of the three players punished in 2018. It is not the finding of any inquiry, and several of the people Bancroft names have publicly and consistently denied knowing about the sandpaper.
What Bancroft says happened
The central line of the statement is blunt. "It was not just the three of us – Steve Smith, David Warner and I – who knew about me using sandpaper on the ball in South Africa. It was the whole team," Bancroft wrote, as published in full by The Guardian. He said that when Cricket Australia investigated in 2018 he "did not give a complete and truthful account," withholding details about when the sandpaper use began, how long it lasted and who else was aware.
BBC Sport summarised his key claims. Bancroft says sandpaper was first used during the second Test in Port Elizabeth, the match before he was caught. He says he talked with seamers Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Mitchell Marsh about whether the ball was "swinging enough," and that the playing group and staff shared "celebrations" about the effect of the sandpaper before day three of that Test. He also singles out then-assistant coach David Saker as someone who encouraged him, and says media manager Kate Hutchison was the one person who objected and walked away from the discussion.
The most vivid passage concerns the moment TV cameras caught him in Cape Town. Bancroft writes that 12th man Peter Handscomb ran out at a drinks break and took the sandpaper from him after then-coach Darren Lehmann radioed an instruction to "get the sandpaper off Bangers now." Bancroft's conclusion, in capitals: "WE ALL KNEW." In the same statement, he acknowledges "a distinction between knowing a ball is reversing, suspecting it has been altered, and knowing specifically that sandpaper has been used," and says his account alone does not settle every question.
Why he spoke now
The saga was reopened earlier this month by retired batter Usman Khawaja's autobiography, Sabr, which suggested the whole team should share responsibility. Warner and former seamer Chadd Sayers backed that view, while Cummins called Khawaja's account "wrong" and "nonsense" in a press conference lasting more than an hour last week, BBC Sport reported.
Bancroft said that press conference was "the final straw," adding that it made him "feel angry, betrayed and alone." Speaking to the Nine Network outside his Perth home on Thursday, he said he felt "really freed" after publishing the piece, according to ABC News. He also revealed that a 2021 joint statement by Cummins, Starc, Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon, denying any knowledge of the plot, had been "deeply painful" to read.
Cummins stands firm
Cummins has not shifted. "Pat's position hasn't changed in eight years," his manager, Neil Maxwell, said in a statement reported by ABC News. "He's been consistent and adamant from day one. Pat feels for Cam, of course. He has been through a lot." Maxwell urged people to reread the transcript of Cummins's press conference, saying there was nothing he had not answered, including in response to Bancroft's latest claims. Lehmann and Starc have also previously reiterated their denials, according to the BBC.
On Thursday, Cummins trained in the nets at the Sydney Cricket Ground with the New South Wales squad alongside Hazlewood, ABC News reported, as he builds up for the first of four home Tests against New Zealand, which starts on December 9.
Cricket Australia's forum, not a fresh investigation
Bancroft's statement landed on the same day Cricket Australia announced an independent forum for players and staff from the 2018 tour. In its official statement, CA chair David Boon said the board had chosen not to open a new investigation. "This is not a re-investigation, it is not designed to reprosecute or sanction," Boon said, adding that no one would be compelled to take part.
According to cricket.com.au, chief executive Todd Greenberg said the confidential process would be run by an independent senior lawyer or former judge, would take about a month, and that the CA board would decide what is made public. Responding to Bancroft, CA said it respected that he had told his story and would "take time to consider his comments." Bancroft says he will take part in the forum.
Reactions and the pressure on the captaincy
Warner, who has criticised CA's handling of the original investigation, told the Seven Network he believed Bancroft had "told the truth" and was relieved for him, ABC News reported. Former New Zealand player Simon Doull went further while commentating on the India-New Zealand Test in Wellington, questioning on Sky Sports how Cummins could survive as captain heading into the New Zealand series.
Those are opinions, not findings. But they show how quickly the conversation has moved from whether the matter should be reopened to whether senior figures in the current set-up can ride it out.
What happens next
In 2018, Smith and Warner were each banned for a year and Bancroft for nine months; no other players or coaches were punished. CA has ruled out new sanctions, so the forum's practical impact will depend on who chooses to take part and how much of its findings the board decides to release. Steve Smith has stayed silent since Khawaja's book came out, and it remains to be seen whether he, Lehmann, Saker or any other named figure responds in detail. BBC Sport called Bancroft's account potentially "the decisive intervention," while stressing it is not open-and-shut evidence against anyone.
For now, two firm accounts sit side by side, and Australia's Test summer starts in less than three weeks. Whether CA's forum brings closure or simply more competing recollections may decide how much of this follows Cummins onto the field.