Entertainment

Home  •  Blog  •  Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Rea...

Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping Splits Critics as Box Office Hopes Soar

Some call the Haymitch prequel a franchise high; others a 'cold cash grab.' Presales, meanwhile, are running ahead of Wicked.

A lone teenage figure with an axe overlooks a vibrant neon jungle arena and a golden tower at sunrise under a half-golden, half-stormy sky

Critics can't agree on whether the new Hunger Games prequel is a triumph or a slog, but ticket buyers appear to have already made up their minds.

The reviews are in for The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping, and they could hardly be further apart. The sixth film in Lionsgate's dystopian franchise, which tells the origin story of a teenage Haymitch Abernathy, has been called everything from "surreally awful" to "one of the best films in the series" as critics weighed in on Tuesday, November 17, according to the BBC. The film opens in theaters on Friday, November 20, and despite the split verdict, it arrives with some of the strongest advance ticket sales of the post-pandemic era.

A Prequel About the Mentor Before the Bottle

Based on Suzanne Collins' novel of the same name, Sunrise on the Reaping follows a 16-year-old Haymitch, played by Joseph Zada, as he is thrown into the 50th Hunger Games, the Second Quarter Quell, in which twice as many tributes are selected. The story is set 24 years before the original film, as the Associated Press noted in its review, and 40 years after the previous prequel, 2023's The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes.

Fans know the adult Haymitch as the hard-drinking mentor played by Woody Harrelson in the original series. The new film explains how he got there. Francis Lawrence, who directed most of the earlier entries, is back behind the camera, and the ensemble is stacked: Ralph Fiennes plays President Snow, with Jesse Plemons, Glenn Close, Kieran Culkin, Elle Fanning, Mckenna Grace and Maya Hawke also in the cast, per the BBC. The PG-13 film runs 158 minutes, People reported.

The Case For: 'A Star-Making Turn'

The film's champions are enthusiastic. TheWrap's William Bibbiani called it the best Hunger Games since Catching Fire and said it strikes the "most effective balance between crowd-pleasing engagement and sobering commentary in the whole series," according to People. He praised Zada for evoking Harrelson "without resorting to imitation" and suggested that "when the dust settles it may even be the Hunger Games that holds up best."

The Hollywood Reporter singled out Zada's performance as a "star-making turn" and described the film as a return to the spirit of the first movies after the disappointing Songbirds and Snakes, the BBC reported. Time Out gave it four stars, calling it "as strong as any" of the earlier films. Little White Lies' Anna Stafford highlighted the visual design, describing the arena as "a technicolour poison paradise" lifted straight from Collins' pages.

The AP's Mark Kennedy also found plenty to like, saying the film leans into themes of resistance against authoritarianism with clear echoes of the present day, and that its arena is lush and dangerous. Longtime fans should note that, according to the AP, a few familiar faces from the original films turn up near the end.

The Case Against: 'A Cold Cash Grab'

The detractors were just as forceful. In a one-star review, The Guardian called the film "overwrought and boring" and argued it exists mainly to draw income from its fanbase, according to the BBC. Screen Daily called it an "underwhelming prequel" that "suffers from a lack of compelling characters," while Empire's three-star verdict described it as "an enjoyable-enough diversion, but essentially a footnote with aspirations."

ADVERTISEMENT

IndieWire's Ryan Lattanzio was among the harshest. He called the film "visually soupy" and "narratively morose," said its action is often lost in "a maelstrom of CGI," and wrote that the movie feels "a little bit like a cold cash grab rather than a necessary deepening of the series' lore," per People. He found Zada "charming enough" but said the character lacks the pull Jennifer Lawrence brought to the originals. The New York Times made a similar point, calling the film a "slog" in which only Plemons and Fiennes briefly lift the material.

Variety's Owen Gleiberman landed somewhere in the middle, observing that the film "essentially replays the plot of the original Hunger Games movie."

What the Scores Say

For all the noise, the aggregate picture is more moderate than either camp suggests. The film held a 70% score from 47 reviews on Rotten Tomatoes as of Tuesday, People reported. That keeps it in "fresh" territory, and several of the positive reviews explicitly framed it as a step up from The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes. The score could still move as more reviews arrive before release.

Box Office: Presales Ahead of 'Wicked'

If critics are divided, early audience demand is not. Earlier this month, Deadline reported that presales for Sunrise on the Reaping were well ahead of Universal's Wicked and were the best Lionsgate had seen for any title since the pandemic, also ahead of Michael, which opened to $97.2 million in North America. Deadline raised its opening-weekend floor to $80 million-plus, up from an earlier $60 million to $70 million forecast, and noted that prediction platform Polymarket put the chances of a $100 million-plus opening at 75%.

The outlet also flagged a caveat: films driven by female audiences can be front-loaded, and strong presales don't always translate directly into a giant opening. For comparison, The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes opened to $44.6 million, the lowest start in the franchise, before finishing at $166.3 million domestically, according to Deadline.

What Happens Next

The real verdict arrives this weekend. Deadline's analysis suggests the prequel faces no blockbuster of Wicked or Moana 2 scale over the Thanksgiving corridor, with Disney Animation's Hexed and the comedy Focker-in-Law each tracking at $40 million to $50 million. The biggest wild card may not be a film at all: Grand Theft Auto VI launches on Thursday, the day before, and could compete for the same young audience's time and money.

For now, the takeaway is simple. Critics are split on whether Haymitch's story deserved its own movie, but if the tracking holds, Sunrise on the Reaping could still deliver the franchise's biggest opening in years. Whether audiences side with the champions or the skeptics will become clear once opening-weekend grosses and audience scores arrive.

Verified Sources & References
TAGS: #The Hunger Games #Sunrise on the Reaping #Movie Reviews #Box Office #Lionsgate #Joseph Zada
SHARE THIS STORY
Entro

Entro

Staff Writer & Senior Contributor

Curating in-depth stories, analysis, and ideas for Enterteno readers. Committed to editorial accuracy, independent reporting, and original perspective.