A Facebook feature that suggested what to post from your camera roll has turned into one of the biggest penalties an Italian authority has ever imposed on a tech company, and Meta says it will fight it.
Italy's data protection authority, the Garante, said on Saturday, November 14, that it has fined Meta Platforms Ireland €805 million (about $887 million). The regulator found that the Facebook app for Android accessed photos, videos and related metadata on Italian users' phones "without obtaining specific consent and without properly informing them," according to the Garante's official statement. Meta now has 60 days to switch the feature off by default and ask users for consent separately. The company has said it will appeal.
What the Regulator Decided
The ruling targets one feature: "Get tips from your gallery while browsing Facebook." It has been available since 2023. While people scroll Facebook, it surfaces photos and videos from their phone's gallery as ideas for new posts. The idea is simple, but the regulator objected to how Meta obtained the access that makes it work.
The Garante's technical analysis found three problems. First, gallery access was requested through a single permission that covered the whole app and several functions with different purposes. Second, that permission prompt came after a generic notice asking users to "enable other features," which did not make clear that they were also turning on gallery suggestions. Third, the feature was switched on by default. Once fully granted, the authority said, this kind of permission lets the app read a device's entire photo archive, usually permanently, and neither the user nor the regulator can check which information is actually used.
The Numbers Behind the Fine
The authority said about 20 million Android users in Italy were affected. It added that the violation is still ongoing for people who have not updated the app and for those who have already granted the permission. In setting the fine, the Garante also pointed to an earlier 2019 decision against the company and to what it called Meta's limited cooperation during the investigation. It counted changes Meta made after the complaint as a mitigating factor, but judged them late and limited to users who update the app.
The authority said the €805 million penalty equals about 0.47% of the group's worldwide revenue. For scale, Meta's turnover reached $201 billion in 2025, with net profit of $60.5 billion, The Guardian reported. The paper described the fine as among the largest an Italian authority has imposed on a tech company. The comparison it gave was Amazon's 2021 competition-law penalty of more than €1.1 billion, which was later cut to €752 million on appeal.
How the Case Came About
The investigation began in July 2025 after a complaint from the Bolzano Consumer Protection Centre, a consumer group in northern Italy, the Garante said. The legal basis is significant. The authority did not rely mainly on the EU's General Data Protection Regulation. Instead it used Article 122 of Italy's Privacy Code, which implements the European ePrivacy Directive. That rule treats a smartphone as part of a person's private sphere. Any access to information stored on the device requires free and informed consent, whether or not the data is transmitted anywhere and whether or not anyone is harmed.
That choice also shaped a jurisdiction fight. Meta argued the case belonged with Ireland's data protection authority, which normally leads EU privacy cases involving the company because its European headquarters is in Dublin. The Garante rejected this, noting that the ePrivacy rules do not include the GDPR's "one-stop-shop" mechanism that sends cross-border cases to a single lead regulator.
Meta Pushes Back
Meta rejected both the finding and the size of the penalty. A spokesperson said "we strongly disagree" with the regulator's assessment and with "the disproportionate level of the fine," The Guardian reported. In a statement carried by CNBC, citing Reuters, the spokesperson defended the tool: "This is a simple feature that helps people share photos and videos on Facebook. Users must grant permission on their device before the feature can operate, and they can change that permission at any time in their settings."
The case does not cover artificial intelligence, a point that matters given wider worries about tech firms using personal content to train models. The Garante said its proceedings did not examine whether gallery content might have been used to train AI, which Meta denies. However, the regulator said it reserves the right to separately examine a newer feature, launched in 2026, that allows gallery content to be processed in the cloud.
Why It Matters
Analysis: The ruling is less about a single Facebook tool than about how apps ask for permission. Bundling many functions under one broad "allow access" prompt is common across the app industry. The Garante's position is that each purpose that touches what is stored on a phone needs its own clear, specific consent. If that reasoning survives Meta's appeal, other apps that use catch-all photo permissions could face similar questions in Italy, and possibly from regulators in other EU countries that apply the same ePrivacy directive.
The decision also adds to a difficult stretch for Meta on data. In late October, New Mexico ordered the company to pay $25 billion for misleading the state's residents about the use of their data for more than a decade, The Guardian noted. Meta criticized that penalty as a "tax" on freedom of expression.
What Happens Next
Under the order, Meta has 60 days to request consent through a separate, specific prompt for gallery suggestions. That prompt must explain what the feature does, that it involves access to the photo gallery, and how to turn it off. The feature must stay off by default, even for users who have already granted permission. If Meta misses the deadline, the feature cannot be turned on for anyone who has not given valid consent. The company must tell the Garante within 30 days what steps it has started and within 90 days what measures it has adopted.
Meta's planned appeal is the next step, while the regulator's separate look at cloud processing of gallery content remains a possible next front. For Android users in Italy, the immediate change should be visible within two months: a new, dedicated prompt asking whether Facebook may dig through their camera roll for post ideas.