Business

Home  •  Blog  •  'Your Appetite Is Never Satisfie...

'Your Appetite Is Never Satisfied': Modi's Jobs-and-Pay Rebuke Puts India Inc on the Spot Before Budget

Two days after the Prime Minister's FICCI speech, companies are defending their pay records as data shows record profits and near-flat real factory wages

Golden balance scale tipped by tall stacks of gold coins on one side against a thin pay envelope on the other, over a rising bar chart

A blunt question from the Prime Minister — "Have you increased the salaries of your employees?" — has India Inc scrambling for answers just as Budget 2027-28 wish lists land on the Finance Minister's desk.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi used the centenary annual general meeting of the Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FICCI) in New Delhi on Thursday, November 19, to deliver one of the sharpest public rebukes of corporate India in years. Two days on, the remarks are still reverberating: companies are lining up to show they are "doing their bit", fresh data analyses are testing his claim, and executives are reading the speech as a warning to temper their pre-Budget demands.

What the Prime Minister said

Modi reminded industry leaders that the corporate tax rate had been cut from 30% to 22% and that earnings up to Rs 12 lakh now carry no income tax. Then he turned on his audience. "I know you won't clap. I know this very well," he said, adding in Hindi that industry's appetite was so large that no amount of support ever satisfied it, according to The Indian Express. "But have you increased the salaries of your employees? Have you increased the number of employees in your organisations? No. You say, 'Modi ji, you do your part, we will see.'"

The criticism went beyond pay. Modi said he felt "ashamed" that some manufacturers treat India's 1.4 billion people as a guaranteed market for sub-par goods, and asked whether Indian consumers were "not entitled to good-quality products". He pointed to import dependence in pharmaceutical ingredients, specialised steel grades and aluminium alloys, noted that India's share of global agricultural exports is only 2-2.5%, and urged companies to use India's free trade agreements to build export markets. Invoking Mahatma Gandhi's call for Swadeshi in the 1930s, he asked whether the fact that he was still repeating the same message after 100 years was industry's "success or failure".

He also struck a conciliatory note, telling business leaders that "the doors of the government, and the mind of the government, are completely open" to reform suggestions, the Financial Express reported.

What the numbers show

Several data points published since the speech lend weight to the Prime Minister's complaint. The Annual Survey of Industries shows the average wage per factory worker rose 5.3% in 2024-25 to Rs 2.28 lakh, but with household inflation at 4.6%, real wage growth was just 0.7% — and that was the best figure in three years, after 0.1% in 2023-24 and a decline of 1.1% in 2022-23, according to The Indian Express. The same data shows the gap between managers and workers widening: a supervisor earned 5.87 times a factory worker's wage in 2008-09, rising to 6.36 times in 2024-25.

Profits, meanwhile, are at records. Around 2,600 listed companies tracked by Bank of Baroda posted net profit of roughly Rs 4.5 lakh crore in the July-September quarter, up nearly 26% year-on-year, though five firms — three of them state-owned — accounted for a quarter of that total. A separate analysis of 4,046 companies found their wage bill grew 9% in FY26 while net profits jumped nearly 19%, and that India Inc's cash balances reached Rs 12.8 lakh crore at the end of September, a five-year high, according to a Financial Express analysis.

ADVERTISEMENT

The picture is not entirely one-sided. The latest survey data also shows the number of people engaged in industry rising 7.2% to 2.1 crore in 2024-25, with total emoluments up 12.1% to Rs 8 lakh crore against profit growth of 7.7%. On a total-payroll basis, then, the wage bill grew faster than profits that year; the weakness shows up mainly in pay per worker after inflation.

How India Inc has responded

The most eye-catching response came from Vedanta. Chairman Anil Agarwal said the group had recently introduced a special "Chairman Grant" giving nearly 100,000 employees an additional 10% of their annual salary, according to Business Standard. Reports indicate the grant covers staff earning up to an undisclosed salary threshold and was credited after an internal memo from the chairman.

Sector associations representing machine tools, mining and material recycling told the paper they shared the Prime Minister's concerns, while listing constraints such as workforce shortages and insufficient domestic scrap supply. One unnamed industry figure blamed "bureaucracy and a parallel economy", and Business Standard noted there was no immediate reaction from the major industry bodies.

Behind closed doors, the mood appears more anxious. Executives were caught off guard and are expected to compile data in the coming weeks to show that employment and wages have risen, citing higher fuel and input costs and a weak rupee as pressures, The Economic Times reported, citing The Times of India. Government sources told the paper that industry could have done more to reciprocate.

Why it matters for the Budget

The timing is pointed. Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman has begun consultations for the Union Budget 2027-28, and FICCI itself has asked for the restoration of the long-term capital gains tax exemption on listed securities, along with a graded structure that lowers rates for longer holding periods. Economists who met the Finance Minister urged her to keep the tax in place on fiscal grounds.

In our reading, the speech raises the bar for any new corporate concessions: companies seeking relief will now be expected to show what they did with the last round. It also aligns with the government's own messaging. The Economic Survey for 2024-25 warned that the disproportionate rise in corporate profits raised concerns about income inequality, and Chief Economic Adviser V Anantha Nageswaran has described India's challenge as less a jobs problem than an income problem. Whether the rebuke translates into broad wage increases, rather than one-off gestures, remains an open question.

What comes next

The next data checkpoint arrives on November 30, when July-September GDP figures are released; after 7.8% growth in April-June, economists widely expect a similar reading. Expect industry bodies to submit employment and wage data alongside their Budget memoranda in the coming weeks — and expect the government to weigh those numbers against the Prime Minister's question as it finalises the Budget.

Verified Sources & References
TAGS: #Narendra Modi #India Inc #Wages #Jobs #FICCI #Budget 2027
SHARE THIS STORY
Entro

Entro

Staff Writer & Senior Contributor

Curating in-depth stories, analysis, and ideas for Enterteno readers. Committed to editorial accuracy, independent reporting, and original perspective.